What gesture does the man make to Hester that suggests he knows her?

• A. He points to Hester and to his lips, indicating hush.
• B. He waves to the crowd.
• C. He taps his cane and points to the crowd.
• D. He points to Hester and then to the air, signaling "shh".

Answer: (D)

The key idea here is how nonverbal cues carry recognition and a hint of secrecy. The man’s gesture—moving his finger from Hester toward the air while signaling hush—reads as a quiet acknowledgment: he knows who she is, and he’s telling her (and anyone watching) to keep quiet about it. This small, discreet gesture fits the scene’s tension about hidden knowledge and the social pressure to conceal sin. It’s a subtle acknowledgment that avoids drawing attention, unlike a public wave or a direct lip-touting hush, which would feel louder or more performative. So this gesture best captures the moment of recognized identity coupled with a request for discretion.